• Home
  • Editorial
  • Contributors
  • Advertising policy
  • Contact Us
Home » The Lighter Side

Ask Bayla #1: Pesach power struggle

Submitted on July 21, 2009 – 1:03 pmOne Comment

Traditionally in Jewish culture, knowledge and wisdom are passed down from the elders to the younger generation.  Together with a historically higher than average literacy rate, this has been one of the keys to Jewish success in education, business, and life learning.

At Galus Australis, we are concerned that our community has forgotten the importance of utilising the wisdom of our elders.  That’s why we’re doing something about it!  We’ve recruited a genuine Zaida, as well as a Tante, to answer any questions our readers might have.

So for those of you who have any questions on any topic whatsoever, please direct them to either Izzy (izzy@galusaustralis.com) or Bayla (bayla@galusaustralis.com), and they’ll be only too happy to tell you what to do. Or where to go.

Dear Tante Bayla,

For the past twenty years, my father-in-law (let’s call him Motek) has been responsible for running our pesach seders. The seder is a contentious ritual in our family – Motek favours a speedy, cut-through-the-maggid-to-the-fressing bit, as does my husband, J. I prefer a more philosophical and intellectual approach; drawing from various haggadot as well as readings from secular-Jewish and non-Jewish sources. My brother-in-law is quite frum and likes a very traditional, Orthodox (and long) seder. My sister-in-law, like Motek and J, just wants to eat ASAP (but I think she’d like all of our our children to participate more).
Anyway, dear Motek is getting on in years and recently announced his abdication from the Head of Seder post. He feels it’s time to pass the role on to the next generation. I can see conflict brewing, come pesach-time. How do we find an amicable way to resolve our differences?

Thanks,
BaSeder, East St Kilda, VIC

Tante Bayla

Tante Bayla

Dear BaSeder,

So, “dear Motek is getting on in years”, is he? Oh, you can barely contain your glee, BaSeder. Admit it! Finally, the alte kaker has bowed out. A power struggle forming! This is your big opportunity to come out on top! And there’s a lot at stake, too – shalom bayis, boredom, plagues, continuity, tradition, whinging children, religious differences, AND MOST IMPORTANTLY, getting to eat your kneidlach before midnight.
BS (hmm), this is a matter of urgency – spiritually, politically, etc. Though you’ve couched it in much more PC-language than I would have – shkoyach! That does, however, say something about the sort of seder you’d run, and I’ll be frank – it’s not my cup of salted water. I’m a Motek sort of gal at heart. After many, many years of seders (of all sorts of ideological and religious affiliations and permutations), I get it. We were slaves, The Almighty redeemed us, now we’re free, let’s all hold hands and talk about Darfur for ten minutes, etc. These days, I just want to eat my roast chicken and gefilte fish and make Masterchef-esque looking korech structures from multiple layers of charoset, lettuce, matzah and maror.
Having said that, I admire your noble, post-modern proclivities. I get where you’re coming from. As far as I can see, there is only one fair way to resolve a power struggle in our post-modern, self-referentially ironic, inter-webzy world: a reality-TV style competition. Truly, is there any greater arbiter of cultural value today than a child with a mobile phone, opposable thumbs and a working television? NO! (Your sister-in-law will love it!) Picture it: SederMaster Australia. A cook-off, read-off, learn-off, source-gathering-off SPECTAC. A different contestant eliminated each week. The process would culminate in a epic, six-hour seder-off, with the winner crowned SederMaster by the children in the family until death (or senility)!

I love it. I’m on shpilkas. Someone get me The Shtick on the phone.

Love,
Tante Bayla

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon

One Comment »

  • Seder Macher says:
    July 28, 2009 at 4:50 pm

    I am the Motek of my family and have been conducting the seder for many years. I like to consider it a benevolent dictatorship – my family tell me their suggestions, I kindly ignore them. They must all be chomping at the bit waiting for me to cark it, however, I will stand firm. No artsy-fartsy, hand-holding, egalitarian mumbo-jumbo at my seder table. Just give it to me by the book, followed a good roast chicken prepared by my good wife.

Leave a comment!

Click here to cancel reply »

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

Notify me of further comments via e-mail

Arts and Culture »

Sydney, get your Arts on!

Sydney, get your Arts on!

By Janis Seftel
“It was great. Really good vibe. But it didn’t really feel like anyone my age was there. I told my friends about it, but I guess people had things on.”
If you’re young, artsy …

More articles »

Community Life »

At least the Maoists won’t be taking power – a global perspective

At least the Maoists won’t be taking power – a global perspective

By Keren Tuch
Whilst I detest listening to our leaders belittling one another in an act of political sabotage, the optimist in me is grateful that I live in a democracy with freedom of speech.  Whilst …

More articles »

Politics and Media »

Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott

Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott

By Larry Stillman
I’d like to argue the moral case for supporting a selective boycott of products from the Occupied West Bank. I take the view that it is illegally held territory in which its prior …

More articles »

Religion and Jewish Thought »

Let the Shofar Take You Places

Let the Shofar Take You Places

By Rabbi Meir Rabi
May this year be a peaceful year.
A year of challenges that prompt us to discover energies that have perhaps hibernated within us and are ready to blossom.
Everyone wants a sweet new year. …

More articles »

The Lighter Side »

Mossad Passport Appeal 2010 – Give Generously

Mossad Passport Appeal 2010 – Give Generously
More articles »

Recent Comments

  • michael on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Larry Stillman on Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott
  • Mark Baker on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Foob on Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott
  • Steve Brook on Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott
  • art finkle on Let the Shofar Take You Places
  • Josh Stein on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Shira Wenig on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • michael on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Ann Fink on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • ariel on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Ann Fink on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Mandi Katz on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • michael on Why I Support the New Zionist Left
  • Sam on Rosh Hashanah – of Fish Heads and Frankl

Galus Australis on Facebook

Become a fan!Our fan site

Archives

  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009

Popular topics

anti-Semitism anti-Zionism Australia Australian Jewish News Australian Jews boycotts CSG culture dilemma Election halacha Holocaust identity Israel JCCV Jewish Jewish Life Jews J Street Julia Gillard Kevin Rudd kosher leadership Limmud Limmud Oz marriage media medicine Melbourne Moshiach Palestine Pesach policy publishing religion saykhel schools and education The Age The Australian The Australian Jewish News The Left The Right Torah transparency Zionism

Random Posts

Look Who’s Afraid of Free Speech Now No Need for Religion to Appreciate the Wonders of the Universe A Spectrum of Observance Nine things to do in Jerusalem Uluru and Halls Creek 1 - another extract from Howard Goldenberg's Two Nations in One Womb - a Dvar Torah Turkey Says Goodbye to Israel and the West The NIF controversy - a chance for closure Everyone loves a boycott! My Cousin Sammy (OR: The single-issue voter: a portrait) Letters to the Editor Let's talk about sex (or gender)
(refresh random posts)

Latest Video Post

Warning: Never Separate a Wedding Reception from a Chuppah

Recent Posts

  • Let the Shofar Take You Places
  • Rosh Hashanah – of Fish Heads and Frankl
  • Why the AJDS are right to support a limited boycott
  • The Midrash Says…
  • Why I Support the New Zionist Left

Most Commented

  • Rabbi Rabi reflects on the so-called soft matzah controversy
  • Confronting the last Taboo - Orthodox Judaism and Homosexuality
  • The Atheist Delusion
  • COSV President Scolds the RCV
  • Soft Matzah: Rabbi Rabi Responds to Rabbinical Council Criticism

Most Popular

  • The Atheist Delusion
  • Jewish Knight Defends Pius XII
  • Rabbi Rabi reflects on the so-called soft matzah controversy
  • Soft Matzah: Rabbi Rabi Responds to Rabbinical Council Criticism
Powered by WordPress | Log in | Entries (RSS) | Comments (RSS) | Arthemia Premium theme byColorlabs Project | Creative Commons License
Text and video content on this site by Galus Australis (and named authors) is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 Australia License.