Letters to the Editor
Letters to the editor should be addressed to editorial at galusaustralis.com
While letter writers do not necessarily have to publish letters under their full/real name, we do require that you provide your real details to us.
Comments related to specific articles published on Galus Australis should be written in the comments section, rather than as a Letter to the Editor. Likewise, general feedback on Galus Australis should be provided in the General Feedback section.
Prayers at simchas need not be clandestine
It always disturbs me how Maariv is conducted at Orthodox – both Modern
Orthodox and Chareidi – simchas in Melbourne.
The way it tends to be done makes it like a furtive, clandestine activity.
Rather than doing it properly as a formal part of the proceedings
announcing it as such, and stopping the band playing for the10 minutes
or so that it would take, what is done instead is that someone decides
that they want to daven Maariv, then furtively goes around recruiting
men for this clandestine assignment. The group then sneaks out, as if on
a special secret-men’s-business mission, finds an out-of-the-way spot,
sometimes in front of a wall of mirrors, and attempts to concentrate on
reciting prayers – despite being in an environment where the continuing
loud music extends out of the hall into the adjoining areas and
corridors at often only a minimally-abated volume (though admittedly,
this is more an issue with some bands than others).
Many people who would have liked to join the group to daven with a
minyan but didn’t realise that it was happening miss out, whilst others
feel pressured to join the group and go through the motions of davening
in an environment where it is impossible to concentrate.
At a Barmitzvah, doing it as a formal part of the proceedings would also
allow the Barmitzvah boy to take part – perhaps even lead the service.
Friday August 29