Home » Anthony Frosh, Community Life, Recent Posts

Birds of a Feather Flock Together – Deal with it!

September 26, 2011 – 12:09 pm3 Comments

A sign marking an old Italian neighbourhood in Toronto

By Anthony Frosh

Box Hill in Victoria has lots of Chinese, Lakemba in NSW has lots of Lebanese, Peppermint Grove in WA has lots of WASPs, and of course, there are a number of areas in Australia that have lots of Jews.

People choose to live near other people from their own ethic group or subculture for a variety of reasons. People’s friends tend to be disproportionately from their own subculture and people in general like to live near their friends. They also want to be near their community infrastructure.  In the case of Shabbat observant Jews, they often have a strong preference to live not only within the eruv, but within easy walking distance of their shul as well as close family/friends whom they regularly eat with over Shabbat.

So, shouldn’t real estate companies and the like be catering to these demographic realities? For example, I am often perplexed by advertisements for residential property auctions that are scheduled on Shabbat in areas not only with a large Jewish  population, but also with a considerable frum population. Often this happens when the seller and the real estate agent are unaware of the Shabbat dynamic.  However, it still sometimes happens with real estate agencies that ought to know better.

Gary Peer is a real estate agency that seems to function almost entirely in the suburbs of Melbourne that are heavily populated by Jews.  And quite incredibly, in the Caulfield area, they seem (from casual observations) to have close to a 65% market share.  While it can be assumed that Gary Peer are aware of the Shabbat dynamic, since they have so many ‘Jewish area’ properties for auction on any given weekend, they probably can’t schedule them all on a Sunday. I like to imagine that they have rather entertaining weekly  meetings where they determine the likelihood of frum Jews being potential buyers for new listings they’ve won, and then make their Saturday vs. Sunday decision on that basis. I’m not sure if this is the reality though.

Sydney based Oschrie Massatschi, founder of the Jewish Living website, bases his enterprise on the idea that Jews have particular real estate needs that are not easily met by general real estate websites. According to Massatschi, “When moving to an unfamiliar country it is difficult for people from the Jewish community (as a minority) to find the right suburb to live amongst like minded people and have the possibility to maintain their Jewish lifestyle and traditions. Jewish Living is the only website in the world to display all relevant Jewish infrastructure and eruvim on maps with contact details of these points of interest. Jewish Living even combines these points of interest with all available properties marked on the maps.”

But Jewish Living doesn’t just cater to home buyers. Jewish Living also functions to help people find flatmates.  Massatschi states that “The desire/need to live with someone Jewish prevents many young Jews to move out of their parents’ home as it is vital for them to live with flatmates that adhere to the same traditions/religion and value the same beliefs, e.g. Shomer Shabbat, keeping kosher, etc”. For example, the Jewish Living website will help someone find share accommodation that has a kosher kitchen.

Massatschi says he has received a lot positive feedback from people who used the website from everything to sell their property to find the perfect flatmate. The site started with a focus on the Sydney market, and has now expanded to Melbourne.  Massatschi says he has even received requests from people hoping the site will expand to other countries such as South Africa.

Print Friendly


  • Leo Braun says:

    “Of course, there are a number of areas in Australia that have lots of Jews. People choose to live near other people from their own ethnic group or subculture for a variety of reasons”!

    • Where we lived … I didn’t hear one word of Polish. I didn’t know such a language existed (to the extent it existed, I knew it was language of goyim). Poland? I had no idea about. Our language of instruction was Yiddish. We wrote in Yiddish, learned history in Yiddish … and studied maths in Yiddish.

    I first encountered Polish language when I was seven, as I entered my first class on the second floor of Talmud Tora. During the first week of studies, when the teacher spoke in Polish, we did not understand a word. So we began to shout: “retzt Yiddish, retzt Yiddish” (speak-our-language).

    We made such a commotion that the shames arrived and turned to us to clarify the issue: “Children, you must learn Polish, because we are in Poland”!

  • Leo Braun says:

    “Birds of a feather flock together – deal with it”!

    • Before the First World War, casteless Jews confined in segregated shtetls (*) didn’t know Polish but Yiddish and some Hebrew. A few who knew some Polish, conversed poorly. Except for doctors, lawyers, and such others of the gifted characteristics in the professional class. Who didn’t inhabit shtetls or wore ethnicity on their sleeve — unlike the conspicuous shtetl Jews. Yet by far, the most significant factor that set Poles and Jews apart was grounded in economics. Where courtesy of the established arenda system, entrepreneurial Jews became estate managers, tax collectors, or merchant capitalists who wallowed in opulence.

    * Shtetl = self imposed ghetto, since the Jewish leaders in positions of responsibility made sure that the segregated kehilot subsisted within the walls ironically built to keep danger out. Consequently in 1791, Catherine the Great of Russia created gigantic internment to horde six million casteless Jews within the area extending from Baltic to Black Sea.

    Incredibly, diabolical apartheid covered 20% of the European Russia as segregated territories grew to include 15 Russian provinces, along with the 10 Polish towns and townlets. What lasted for 130 years during 1791-1917 period. Shrouded by the obscure designation: “Pale of Settlement” (in fact concealing hideous plot), denoting burning stake (pale) of the final solution (settlement). Astute readers to peruse American Jewish Committee observations, depicted on page 308 of the published “A Great History of a Great People”!

  • Leo Braun says:

    A Boon or Bane for Jews in Poland?

    Religious freedom and the self-governance assurance were strong incentives for the Jews to move into Polish territories as in 1264 King Boleslav (Boleslaw/Boleslaus) issued a charter — giving industrialist Jews complete freedom under the privilege known as Kalisz Statute. Regulating Jewish legal and social status in Poland until the 18th century. Founding of the Kehila/Kahal institutions and the Council of the Four Lands. What allowed entrepreneurial Jews to engage in trade and the money-lending.

    Although it would seem that the oligarchic magnates, distinguished by their wealth and land holdings, selected likewise ambitious Jews for an arenda mission because of their personal ability to cover the leasing cost of the arenda, as well as due to their managerial expertise, as it turned out … it was the Kahal who selected arendars for the magnates (arenda system = arrangement to lease magnate estates, mills and distilleries, etc).

    Council edits of 1671 and 1677 prohibited Jews from leasing estates or farming from the landlords without the knowledge of the Kahals to which they belonged. These orders gave authority to the Kahals to compel the prospective arendars to purchase a license in order to bid on arendas lease (the Kahal would issue a licence for a fee). At the same time Kahal persisted to prohibit Jews from using Gentiles as a silent partner (utilised to get around the bidding for an arenda without a license).

Leave a comment!

You must be logged in to post a comment.